American political conflict today is no more vicious than in past eras—the 1790s, the 1850s sectional crisis (e.g., the caning of Charles Sumner), the 1920s Red Scare, and McCarthyism—so complaints about today's 'tone' overstate a historically mild period; what is genuinely different is the proliferation of media outlets that outpaces the supply of talent, giving weak minds strong larynxes.

factualpending

Speaker

George Will

Evidence Quote

revisit the 1850s with the sectional crisis... when Preston Brooks, congressman from South Carolina... beat Charles Sumner, the senator from Massachusetts, nearly to death with his Preston Brooks cane.

Source

George Will on America, Politics, and Baseball 2/28/2011EconTalk
Created: 6/15/2026, 9:26:54 AM

My Notes

Loading notes...