Charles Platt
About
Author, journalist (former Wired contributor and science fiction writer), guest who worked undercover at Walmart
Claims by Charles Platt (20)
Low-level Walmart associates have independent authority to reorder merchandise and to set up discounted 'value-price' specials on pallets—printing their own price stickers and slashing prices on high-margin items—with little apparent oversight, and the most successful weekly initiative is rewarded with a voucher.
Walmart operates in a state of constant competitive anxiety, with managers weekly checking competitors' prices and adjusting, and paying a polling company to make random weekly calls to assess customer satisfaction—reflecting a Silicon Valley-style 'we could be driven out of business at any moment' mindset.
By delegating ordering and pricing decisions to the frontline employee who interacts daily with customers, Walmart keeps management costs very low and gains an information advantage—finding things competing stores don't know about—while accepting only a small risk that an individual occasionally errs.
Walmart's flat hierarchy (associates, department managers, assistant manager, manager) combined with peer-group pressure and a store-profit-tied annual bonus creates self-policing: employees avoid stupid risks because mistakes hurt their own and colleagues' bonuses and could get them fired.
Walmart employees were genuinely happy to be there because the alternatives were worse and because Walmart treated them well largely by leaving them alone—well-defined procedures and good employee selection meant workers could do their jobs without the constant petty harassment common in smaller stores.
The Walmart workers Platt spoke to were well aware of their alternatives, actively comparing deals across employers and planning their futures (e.g., evening classes), so they do not need much external protection because they are protecting themselves—contradicting the elite assumption that they are exploited because they 'don't know any better.'
Conditioning one's shopping and economic interactions on whether counterparties are 'ethical' is largely unworkable, because verifying such facts and keeping them current is enormously time-consuming; pursuing it strictly would leave you poor and exposed to others judging you unworthy of interaction in turn.
Platt rejected academic economics as a science after studying it at Cambridge, because its claims—like supply and demand curves intersecting—could not adequately answer questions about where the data and curves come from or how they account for sudden shifts in preferences, leading him eventually to find Hayek's arguments more persuasive.
Walmart's two-day orientation plus an extensive self-administered computer-based training program (covering everything from safe lifting to customer greeting and which jokes are safe to tell) is designed to make employees more valuable, because offending a customer enough that they never return could cost the store hundreds of thousands of dollars in future revenue.
My Notes
Loading notes...